How old are they? I found that my hens went through weird scared phase when they were gawky "teenagers". My Buff Orpington was never terribly interactive until the 1st time she went broody. She'd either ignore us or run away from us. Now she's a sweetheart and I can pick her up and carry her around. Sometimes she'll even jump into my lap on her own and preen her feathers.
Another thing I've found is the "giant hand from above" is much more terrifying than if you are more on their level. Sometimes I get in the brooder (now that the new babies are bigger and in a bigger brooder) with them and they will hop onto my knee and sometimes into my hand, as long as I'm not acting like I'm going to grab anyone.
How many babies do you have? It seems like smaller batches yield sweeter babies too. My 1st batch was only 5. 2 were lovers from the start, 2 were indifferent, and 1 was a terrified spaz. As they got older, the 2 lovers stayed nice, though one is a little less interested in loving than she used to be, 1 became a lover, 1 stayed indifferent, and 1 stayed terrified. Now I have 19 babies and only a couple are showing any interest, but I'm not sure that any would if I didn't get in with them.