Hi Starfire, I´ve missed some of your posts, so sorry if I repeat anything that´s already been said.
Finding an egg in the pool isn´t anything much, they´re just youngsters and usually don´t get it together. Also, some breeds tend to be better brooders than others.
Are they actually broody? Or just laying? It´s very difficult to stop a goose from brooding, but then some have stronger instincts than others. Is one actually glued to a nest site?
For about 4 nights I have had to go and physically lift Peaches off the nest. The first night I thought she was dead in the nest and she totally scared me! The past 2 nights I have had to do the same with Ebony. Both hissed at me when I first touched them. So I am thinking both are feeling the urge to brood.
My mom asked me today to let them hatch babies, she wants to see little fuzz butts running around. I am torn, I really, really didn't want hatchlings this winter, but my mom hasn't been feeling well and I'd like to make her smile. I could put up a dog playpen fence up and section off a piece of the goose coop at night, and open it up in the morning, but I don't know if that would be good enough for Peaches and Ebony. I also don't know if a goose and duck would mind nesting so close together. They lay their eggs that close, but hatching babies might be a different story. Anyone have ideas or suggestions? If I do let them nest, what's the minimum number of eggs to give them? Both would have to sit on goose eggs, the Cayuga ducks aren't laying yet or I'd let Ebony have some of those.