Help me choose breeds?

I have buff orpingtons and my DH loves them because they are so docile and calm. I've not had a broody one yet

 

My barred rock girls are friendly, extremely cold tolerant, because they have small combs, and they lay well even in winter. I would stay with this breed but the roos have huge combs that are prone to frostbite.
I have ordered chanteclers for this spring...next to no combs, are extremely cold hardy and friendly, but will brood. The barreds aren't as broody, rarely brood at all. You are right about orpingtons, they really get broody, and I found they eat an awful lot of feed.

RIR hens are not mean, but the roosters can be, from what I hear. I have had both and never had a problem. I have to say though, they are amazing layers and do not get broody. They are also quite cold hardy from what I hear...I've never had them over the winter though

 

If you can swing it, some Polish hens are the best !

 

I love my barred rocks! I aint never had Orpingtons so I caint help ya there, and yes, RIR's can be a little wild at times LOL!

 

I am a fan of the buffs but they do go broody and if they set on feritle eggs they will hatch them, raise the chicks and then before you know it go broody again! I like australorps too but they are broody too. If you want a all around good bird go for the barred rocks, they don't go broody as much. I am not that knowledgable on EEs. They are good layers too and winter hardy but I don't know if they are broody. RIR reds are another good layer that doesn't go as broody as much.

 

Ps. Polish are reputed to never go broody Alas, they also are not known as stellar layers, though they can be as good as any other - good luck!

 

I've had lots of RIR and NHR hens and neither are mean as a rule, and both do go broody but only occasionally, which is kinda nice! The roosters of either can be overly protective. My NHR roo was very nice to me, but grumpy around others. *shrugs* There's no sure thing really.

Have a look here at this site. It really has some pretty good insights about temperment, cold tolerance and laying abilities and lots more! I think it's pretty spot on, especially on the page that the builder (John Henderson) does only the breeds he's had personal experience with. Though I don't see any real faults on he main page either, at least not on the ones I've either met or have read up on. I think most here will agree that it's a really good reference site.

http://www.ithaca.edu/staff/jhenderson/chooks/dual.html

The link to the full 'main' list link is up in the first paragraph and is called the - ICYouSee Handy Dandy Chicken Breed Chart

[edit] I'm personally going to try some Buckeyes this spring, they seem like good solid birds. We'll see!!

 

Of my 7 hens, my 2 buff orps, 1 barred rock, and 2 light brahmas are all "lap friendly" and have never once pecked my hand. I even dig the eggs out from under them in the nest boxes, and other than making some pretty funny little sounds, they have never ever pecked me. (well, ok, once when I was dumb enough to polish my fingernails RED) My last 2 hens are Black Stars, and while they never peck at me, they never jump up in my lap.

I think a real important point is that you'll be picking up your eggs regularly. If they are allowed to accumulate, perhaps that is what "triggers" the hens to go broody. I pick my eggs up 2 or 3 times a day, and haven't had a hen go broody yet.

Hope this helps!