Hold on... don't confuse "unsubscribe" with changing / deleting your account!
We would never advise that someone change accounts / delete their account to get emails... especially without 100% knowing that is the problem.
We have thousands of members getting emails every day, so it is unlikely a problem with our system sending emails. Your account looks like it is configured properly.
You seem to be using an email from your own domain server which is probably blocking emails. I'd try using a different email address with BYC... maybe an email account with a system like Gmail or Hotmail, then link it to your account, and see if you get the emails at that point. That will at least help isolate where the problem is.
I have gmail and am having the same problems as the OP!