Hen caught eating an egg

Melontine

Songster
6 Years
May 26, 2019
356
1,172
246
Maine
I was sent this photo evidence of one of my hens eating an egg.
IMG_5791.jpeg



This is Basalisk, a 2yr old Olive Egger. The eye witness reported that they saw he carrying something white, then throw it on the driveway and start eating.

Egg eating isn’t great, but I think it’s important to know where she got the egg from before making a decision to her fate. A dropped egg on the ground is fair game. An egg from the coop means something else, and is behavior I think I’d need to cull before other birds begin adopting it.

For her to get from the coop, she would need to steal an egg from under my broody hen, take it from that enclosure, make it through the yard, then hop over the fence, all without another hen taking the ‘treat’ back from her.

Another thing is the color. We don’t have any white egg layers. The closest would be cream or light blue.

I think it’s possible my light blue layer Kida has been keeping a secret nest elsewhere or she also has been known to drop eggs in strange places before. I think it’s more likely the case that Basalisk didn’t take from the coop, but somewhere on the ground where Kida left it.
(Adding to this likelihood, Kida is known to wander the whole yard and hop the fence herself.)

A third possibility;
It’s not a chicken egg but an egg of a wild bird who had made its nest somewhere on the property. Think this works best for carrying purposes, as chicken eggs can be quite large where as a ground dwelling song bird may be much smaller.
-The yolk looks really large though.


Plan of action for right now;
Monitor.
Track how many eggs we are getting from the coop each day, watch Basilisk for further signs of thievery.

Provide more oyster shell.
Supplement calcium as deficiency can definitely contribute to starting this behavior.
I often give my hens the egg shells back when I cook, I will withhold them for the time being.

Plan to cull if necessary.
I can’t keep a hen who eats eggs from our coop. I can’t have that behavior being adopted by my other hens or the young chickens.


Is there anything else you would recommend? Thoughts or your own experiences with similar issues?
 
Egg eating doesn't indicate a need for calcium but a need for protein.
Blow out and fill eggs with yellow/orange dish soap and check the diet for nutritional deficiency .

Huh, wouldn’t have suspected protein. They’re on a feed with higher than normal protein content currently since I have the younger birds being mixed in, but I can definitely look into it. Thanks!
 
No egg shell in the picture
exactly. How much do you trust the eye witness? I don't think it's possible for a hen to carry a soft-shelled or membrane-only egg.
I think it’s important to know where she got the egg from before making a decision to her fate.
I concur.
 
Fair enough. This is all second hand and the witness was watching from a distance, as she was sitting on the front porch of the house when the hen came by. This same hen has caused witness trouble before such as digging and eating seeds out of her garden bed.

Witness stated she saw Basilisk carrying something white in color, she watched her a while trying to figure out what it was. Then the hen dropped it, and the egg broke on the pavement. Witness said that Basilisk ate the shell first.
 
I don't think it's possible for a hen to carry a soft-shelled or membrane-only egg.
I have seen my hens carrying membrane-only eggs, so I'm positive they can.

@Melontine I don't think eating a soft egg is necessarily a bad mark for a hen, they don't seem to treat them the same, I've had hens do it before who never had any problems eating or breaking real, regular eggs. And soft eggs can be laid suddenly, often out of the nestbox so she might not have even taken it from a nest. It does mean they could probably use more calcium/protein, or something else is lacking in the diet. Or it might be heat stress depending on your location and temperatures. Or it could be genetic and one of your hens may just have issues producing proper shells, I've had one or two hens who were habitual soft-shellers. Unlikely for her to successfully eat the entire shell with no pieces left over, but they do often eat the membrane first when I've seen them get a soft-shelled egg.
 
Fair enough. This is all second hand and the witness was watching from a distance, as she was sitting on the front porch of the house when the hen came by. This same hen has caused witness trouble before such as digging and eating seeds out of her garden bed.

Witness stated she saw Basilisk carrying something white in color, she watched her a while trying to figure out what it was. Then the hen dropped it, and the egg broke on the pavement. Witness said that Basilisk ate the shell first.
Could the witness be trying to frame basilisk for digging in the garden bed?
I'm getting too involved in this chicken drama 😂
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom