Thanks again for your advice , gjensen. I do try to go about things with a purposeful approach. Sometimes there are just conflicting goals and approaches that I need to sort through in my mind and it helps if somebody puts a clear approach in writing, like you did. It would indeed be very easy to get a random Barred Rock "roo" ( sorry, couldn't resist), put him over my hens and be done with it![]()
To purposeful, you will have to get to know them. That is hard to tell in one year. It takes a couple generations to figure out what you really have. You figure out what you have by the performance of the offspring they are producing. You have to hatch enough per hen, to see what you really have. 4 eggs from a hen does not represent her (or the cock) well. It is like rolling dice. You might get some sixes, or you might get some ones. Once you get 16 eggs hatched from a hen, you have a better idea what you are dealing with. The dice is weighted and the averages work out with some numbers. Even if that takes two years.
It is not just the individual birds that you are looking at, but the family behind those birds. There is more at work concerning influence than what we see up front.
Now you do not have to do any of this. It can be simplified. What I am trying to illustrate is what it takes to know what you have. You know what you have once you have put a generation or two on the ground. The proof is in the pudding, so to speak. Some of the problems that you identify in the first generation, may still be a problem in the second. Now is there enough variation to make improvements, or is some added variability necessary? What can you live with for now, and what can you not live with? All of that is up to you.
I will leave this one alone. I have not tried to be discouraging. I have also not tried to give advice. I know nothing about your flock. I have only tried to stir some thought and conversation. I am still learning myself.