Apparently the U of A strain started with hatchery stock. It was from cackle if I remember right. I suppose if anyone could breed hatchery stock to look good, it would be a poultry professor.This would be a very valid point, but they are not pure White Houdan. They received serious infusions at the time of rediscovery in order to lift them out of the hole they were in. Every once in a while one will pop up with good shoulders, which betrays the presence of Piper's old Mottled line recently added.--now if only Piper's old line were still around en force instead of creeping around buried in a color project.
The greatest obstacle I've watched with beginners is color. The heart of a chicken is in its type; it's in its body. The ideal Houdan is to have one of the most fantastic types available for meat in poultry, but it has been decimated, absolutely ravished. The closest hatchery bird I found to being the right shape was from Hoffman Hatchery out of Gratz, PA, but they were way too small. The MMcM birds just simply weren't Houdans. I ordered a really large order of MMCM cockerels trying to find something to use, and they were amazingly worthless, utterly amazingly worthless. Multiple years later, I still can't get over how ridiculously bad they were.
Now there is this U of A strain I've never worked with them, maybe I would have made different decisions concerning our breeds back then, had I known about them. Regardless, Bentley apparently backs them as worthy (I hope I'm not putting words in your mouth, Bentley), which is saying sommething. Before I would have sad that Houdans are already gone, that their only possibility of return would be through an out-cross to Dorkings, but if this U of A strain is up to snuff and meets SOP weights--WOW. If this is true, than I'd putit out there that there's absolutely nothing worth grabbing outside of it, save, perhaps, the gent on here who seems to have a remnant of Pipers line. If the U of A strain is worthy, then they are the Hail Mary pass last best great hope. If a group of folks began uniquely with this one strain and cooperated closely for a decade, Houdans could be back on the map again as a bird really worth working with--think ALBC Buckeyes, but this will only come about through that kind of discipline.
Starting beginners on White Houdans would only lead to disappointment and abandonment of the project. They're like scrappy Leghorns with a puff--delicious scrappy Leghorns--but scrappy Leghorns nonetheless. It will take a very strong and maintained effort to get them up to SOP, and in that time the Mottleds will have been neglected. At this point, every Houdan breeder counts, and that's the biggest difference between now and when the first White Houdans were developed via outcrossing.
Now's the ideal time to figure out how to get some of those U of A Houdans into your pens. There's got to be some way to make them accessible. With a little fervor and singleness of heart, all things are possible.