I agree that if one isn't into it for maximum egg production, it's better to let them take a break.Ah, I did know that it is daylight hours that affects egg laying. Also, molt and broodiness. My cochin cross went broody last spring then had a stress molt while raising chicks then her normal molt in the fall. She hadn't laid in nearly a year. I expect her to go broody again this spring. sigh. I don't have a rooster because I live on less than 1/4 acre in a development. I had to buy 10 hour old chicks and insert them at night. I give her credit for raising the babies... and I learned a lot!
I have a small coop and would not chance lighting during the shorter days. Too dangerous for my girls. I also think that the natural cycle with the winter rest is good for the hens even if I do miss the eggs terribly.
This year I hope to acquire a larger coop.
I caution those with hens that aren't actively laying to feed an all flock, grower or finisher ration rather than layer. Provide oyster shell at all times if any are laying.
That will give the birds a better chance at a long life.
I have 4 pullets born last April. 3 out of four started laying in late July and then stopped in October. I didnt use a light through the winter. Yesterday I checked the box and to my surprise there were 2 eggs. I would not have expected them to lay for another month or so. Can someone help me to understand this. Not complaining just interested.
Days are approximately 1.5 hours longer now than they were in late December. I'll bet that's it.