Good post! I have always said this about line breeding, "If it works, it's linebreeding, if it doesn't, it's inbreeding"When I started out with genetics (Asiatic Parrots) someone gave me some very simple but easy to understand advice that I have never forgotten. I do accept that is an extremely simplified concept but it is good for a start.
This concept applies to those genetic traits that can be passed from both mom and dad and can be received by both male and female chicks.
The concept is that any trait that is received from both parents so that the baby has two copies of the trait is going to be expressed in a greater way in the baby. Consider it a multiplication effect.
In breeding or Line breeding is a good example of people using the above concept. They are selectively breeding related birds that are known to share a common "desired" trait to increase or improve the expression of that trait in the babies.
The problem is that this concept also applies to undesired traits. If a baby receives a double dose of a negative trait then we end up with a baby that is likely to experience the multiplied effect of that negative trait.
So the success (or failure) of in breeding or line breeding is ultimately going to be dependent upon the presence of both the positive and negative traits in the birds you wish to breed - and this is where your knowledge of your birds is going to help you with your decision making as to which birds to use.
As an additional note: I have always adopted the breeding policy of alternating each generation of breeding between in line and outcrossing. On each alternate generation, I endeavour to outcross to a completely unrelated, strong, well structured bird. This way I am always working towards my desired trait but not compromising the quality of my birds at the end. I have seen too many people do multiple consecutive line-breeds which result in outstanding colours but where their birds are also small, weak and with a whole library of undesirable issues. It is my opinion that it is best to take a few more generations but end up with birds you can be proud of!
