Well I moved some birds around, one of which was my Good Shepard BR roo. While I was moving I realized I had a barred pullet I could put with him so he could practice and he KNEW EXACTLY what to do with her. So I don't know what was going one. Maybe I need to add the hens to HIS pen and not him to THEIR pen.
I put another roo in with them, so we will see what happens with him. Maybe he will be more dominate and get me some fertile eggs. If not I am going to do some TRIMMING!
