if you want to breed correct looking marans you have to see the equality and the importance of both ;Dark eggs genes and correct looking marans . if you start to prefer one over the other ,you will never be able to breed correct all rounded marans .I have the habit of doing the same thing.
Comparing my Marans to folks who have been breeding for years and have improved their line.
I sometimes want to just cull them all and start over.
If I were to do that, I would STILL have faults to breed out.
The elusive perfect Marans that I am striving to breed will be a life long process.
As Chooks man says, "We work with what we have".
There are steps to take in breeding to improve them.
Do your hens lay dark eggs? To me, this is #1 question which allows me to decide whether to keep or cull. Egg color is what defines a Marans.
If the eggs are dark, I will keep and work toward SOP from there.
there is few breeds out there lay dark eggs .Welsummer is one of them and there is more ,but that does not make them marans . they are just dark eggs layer. you don t want to have just dark eggs layer .
balance has to be achieved between egg color and correct body type . other wise it is not marans what we are breeding .
chooks man