if we are talking about a show bird than less is better .few spots less is better
chooks man
There are some points that are constant in this thread and make sense to me.
We need to strive for balance in the breeding program.
Example - no hackle hen to overcolored roo
or mahogany hackle high colored hen to no magohany shoulder or halo hackled roo
or no feather legged to heavy feather legged
I liked the Curtis Hale article too. He shared his experiences with his lines following the above practice. As he said in the article all lines are different. We have to do the work to figure out how to fix our lines and improve them. I don't think there are hard and fast rules about any of the color questions. A great bird with too much copper on his breast might be just what you need.
Show birds are necessarily breeders. We could get a show bird from a total outcross (happens in dogs a lot) but he wouldn't be any good in breeder department - he would not be able to reproduce himself We should contain our lines with linebreeding.
A lot is fixable but some birds would take way too long. When you aren't sure what kind of bird is in the picture (supposed to be a BCM) - it is time to start over..... but that doesn't mean if the bird is pretty good over all with a couple of problems we throw that bird away. That has been the message in the past but what I have learned here is we just need to fix the problem with a breeding program. We have to become BCM breeders.
For me I really didn't even know what they were supposed to look like. People would post a picture, it would be critiqued for faults and I still didn't understand. That is my fault too. I wasn't doing the work I should have.
I am learning a lot..... thanks to all that post pictures..... a very big help.