I was at the Italian national poultry championships in Dec. 2018. Here are a couple Marans.
This Black Copper Maran rooster took Best of Breed with a score of D96 (Distinguished, 96 points. Maximum possible score at this show was E97, Excellent 97 points).
The two comments the judges made of things that could be better were something about the lobe of the comb (I can't make out the word in my photo of the cage tag) and tail is a bit high.
View attachment 1648690
This Black Maran hen scored B92 (Buono, Good, 92 points). The one noted defect was that the comb is irregular, also things that could be improved was the white in the leg feathers, and something about the ears. They said the general form and shape are good.
View attachment 1648696
If you're interested, I'm posting lots of photos from that show in this thread:
https://www.backyardchickens.com/threads/italian-national-poultry-championship-dec-2018.1288055
the lobe of the comb is a back part of it .should be lifted not touching the neck .
this rooster has too many majors faults .can not score D96.
here the fault I see . his shoulders are not fully coloured . they are patches of red not a uniform rich red copper { Mahogany type } shoulder . very very very important .
he look small to me ,but he is caged and not relax .so I can not tell his tail and over all look . but he is not pretty for sure .
I like his comb ,has a great point .texture
love his rich red copper ,hackle and lancets .will be nice if he has a red shoulders .
the Hen I agree with a judges but not with they score .
the comb is bad
the earlobe are grey /white { Sablee' in French} disqualify
parasitic white feathers on her legs is a disqualify .
she should be disqualify . but I understand it is hard for the judges in the small show .they try to encourage peoples .so my hat to them . they are doing the best they can ,
chooks man