If you have a McGraw strain, I'd keep it.
I don't know where gram got hers, but they aren't too bad really. The new ones aren't as good overall, but the roos have good size, and everyone has yellow speckle feet, which is ideal. We've got good eyes, and most of the hens have the right 1 of 3 white speckle pattern. Mostly good combs, but only one roo of the new bunch has a really good one with the 5 clear points. The other two are going to be set aside. I'm probobly going to hatch a group from each male out of differnt hens, to see what genetics they are throwing out. You never know whats hidden from new ones, and you do have to keep them for 6-9 monthes to get a feel for size they are producing, and such. Remember, go by the points when your picking what to keep. some things are worth a greater percentage, so aim for those, and other things are only worth 5 pts, so its less important at the offset. If you have a good layer, keep her! As a breed, that aspect really needs improving.
Got pics? We should all post and debate togather. I've got the APA here, and then the Java site has the short list of real important things to breed for, plus they'll connect you with the lady who's trying to find out whos got chicks from where, and she'd want some McGraw eggs if you've got them. I'm sending her eggs from grams closed flock this spring.
Thanks for letting me take part. I was bumming when I felt like I wasn't really invited.