- Jan 20, 2011
- 41
- 9
- 76
Quote:
Back in the 30's Marsden and Martin said when homozygous for slate (DD) the bronze color would be completely diluted resulting in a comparatively clear, light slate or "Lilac" individual which would breed true when mated among themselves.
This is what I raise.
What Glenn Drowns of Sandhill calls a lilac is not the same geneotype so IMO should not be called a lilac. He has the genotype of his all mixed up anyway.He lists sl as his slate gene and that is the recessive slate gene, (No longer in the US as far as anyone knows). I have also seen pics of what Glenn calls lilacs and also asked the people what the results were when they bred them to non slate birds and it was obvious to me from the results that the dominate slate gene D is what is actually in his combo not sl. As when you breed sl to a non slate then you will not get any slate phenotypes out of it, but with dominate slate D to non slate, slate phenotypes will come out, and that is what happened so that proves right there that his are actually dominate slate.
Anyway we should not be using the exact same names for birds of different genotypes, each should have their own unique variety name.
Marsden and Martin put the name lilac on b+b+DD first so that should be the one we use for this genotype and not for any other one.
That's my opinion on it.
Kevin
Back in the 30's Marsden and Martin said when homozygous for slate (DD) the bronze color would be completely diluted resulting in a comparatively clear, light slate or "Lilac" individual which would breed true when mated among themselves.
This is what I raise.
What Glenn Drowns of Sandhill calls a lilac is not the same geneotype so IMO should not be called a lilac. He has the genotype of his all mixed up anyway.He lists sl as his slate gene and that is the recessive slate gene, (No longer in the US as far as anyone knows). I have also seen pics of what Glenn calls lilacs and also asked the people what the results were when they bred them to non slate birds and it was obvious to me from the results that the dominate slate gene D is what is actually in his combo not sl. As when you breed sl to a non slate then you will not get any slate phenotypes out of it, but with dominate slate D to non slate, slate phenotypes will come out, and that is what happened so that proves right there that his are actually dominate slate.
Anyway we should not be using the exact same names for birds of different genotypes, each should have their own unique variety name.
Marsden and Martin put the name lilac on b+b+DD first so that should be the one we use for this genotype and not for any other one.
That's my opinion on it.
Kevin