I never reuse the metal ones either. I won't even use the lids that come in the cases of new jars. I only use those for plain storage because they already have a ring imprint on the rubber because they tighten down the rings.I have never even seen Golden Harvest brand before. I haven't been in a Freds in years either. I have to believe that a good number of people that hate Tattler lids are using them wrong. If you have canned for a long time then doing it the same is a reaction and you have to be careful about the tightness on those lids. I didn't think there were stupid people canning because it is not the easiest thing in the world to do but there are. I have read many reviews on people reusing ball lids (for canning not storage in the fridge) until they refuse to reseal. That is too big of a risk for me both health and money wise. I do huge batches, what would happen if an entire batch failed?