I currently have 9 hens and 3 Roos. Since I broke it down to this amount, (they were born 10 Roos and 9 hens) I’ve been concerned for 1 roo. My alpha Tiger millionaire and his second Aragorn have an area split worked out, and they get along fine. Aragorn is very submissive. Then there’s Red, he’s lovely, but he crows incessantly and roughly plays rapey chasey too often. I’ve had the bucket out to cull him 3 times, and he got a reprieve, like sudden thunder storm, or family emergency.
the males don’t bother Red, but I’ve seen him punk out at them, like run up to Tiger, kick up and jump, then run for his life, he doesn’t even hit Tiger, and Tiger doesn’t even chase him.
However, the hens HATE Red. If he gets one, 2 or more other hens run over and pull him off, he’s missing a lot of feathers in the side neck areas. They don’t really hurt him, no pecking no cuts. So I just keep letting him stay, I keep telling him his days are numbered.
I took him out to the breeder with some gals, I wanted his clutch first in case I have to cull him. When I prepared to put him back, he and Aragorn threatened each other thru the wire at first, but by the next day they were ignoring each other, I put him and his gals back in, and it returned to biz as usual. I removed Tiger Millionaire to the breeder with some girls, and Aragorn became alpha, and Reds life didn’t change. I put Tiger back, return to original behaviors.
the best advice is, give them lots of hides and space, get more hens ASAP, and just be prepared to cull. Don’t assume not crowing means submission, Tiger Millionaire does not crow and Aragorn crows maybe twice a week. They’re happy so they don’t complain.