So I keep ducks, I guess I'm qualified to answer. YES brood them separately unless your chicks like getting wet. They are so, so messy. I hate brooding them, but as adults they're great-more gentle on the lawn. If you want eggs, Khaki Campbells are the best. I love mine, and they're very quiet. We had Pekins and Welsh Harlequins for a while. I sold those because they are SO FREAKING LOUD I couldn't stand them. My rooster was quieter and better mannered. The females would go QUAAAAAAACK! QUACK-QUACK-QUACK-QUACK QUACK at five in the morning. The neighbors were fine with it. I couldn't stand them. They didn't like me either. My khaki campbells, on the other hand, are respectful and cautious and a little high strung, but are so quiet by comparison-quieter than my chickens. I even got them a boyfriend this summer.Can anyone give me the scoop on ducks? Do I have to brood them separately from chicks? What breeds other than pekin TSC tends to get? Super messy? Which breeds are better layers? Are certain breeds louder? I had DH talked into a pair of ducklings this morning but all they had were pekin and my understanding is that those are more of a meat duck?
I'm also raising almost silent muscovies for meat. They're really good and sweet tempered. I'm keeping their wings clipped though, because they so fly.