I, personally, love the Calicos better but I get so many that pop out from different breedings that Calicos are not hard for me to get. I can move a lot of the brighter colors out while most folks don;t care for the dark ones. However, my darker girls are the ones I am finding better type on so I breed and breed those crosses a good bit.
I think your roo is very nice. I know you want him to have a better paint job but he has some really pretty color to him. I have one held back like that for my buff Mottled girls. That is for next year though. I am tired of raising chicks right now and am only hatching about 6-12 a week. I know for good results I need to breed more but it is too hot and I have too many projects so I will watch these new ones grow up and plan for a big hatching next spring. Fall will find me culling hard again.