So basically she was not in the tree this morning, I came back inside for a bit 30 mins or so then went back outside to check again and she was not in the tree she was down on the street drinking out of a puddle. I tried to get her to come over by shaking the worm bag but she wouldn't come, then I opened my garage door and tried to just very slowly walk behind her to push her into my garage and close the door behind her, I got super close into our driveway but then she flew into a different closer neighbor's tree. Since she was so close I went to the back to let the ducks out and fill the pool so it looked nice and appealing but when I came back out she was nowhere to be seen. I jumped on my electric scooter to search around the neighborhood and I found her foraging in somebody's yard 1 street over so I went up to her with mealworms to see if I could get close enough to grab her and she did come up and grab a bill full off meal worms out of my hand but not in a way that I could confidently grab her.
My next idea was to grab one of her sisters and see if I could use her to lure in the Puffin, I went back to the coop and grabbed her sister Karen then walked 1 street over and she was very interested, I put Karen down on the ground in a way that I was still holding her and Puffin came right up excited to see her and say hi, however she still did not get close enough for me to confidently grab her and I did not want to try and fail and make things worse. Basically I just stood up and while holding Karen I very slowly walked behind Puffin to herd her into the right direction and surely enough after a long walk I managed to walk her all the way home!!
The video is attached of me walking her back home for anyone who wants to see it, skip to the end if you just want to see her reuniting with her sisters