The only chicken pictured that I can actually see pointed sickle feathers on is Fatty - he's definitely a rooster.
I see rounded saddle feathers on Tony, but in that particular pic can't see the pointed ones. If Tony is a roo, I'm surprised that his comb & wattles are not bigger than they are - My 6 1/2 month old BA pullet has about the same size wattles & comb as Tony has and she's younger - I would think an 8 month old BA cockerel should have a huge comb & wattles by now.
Here's my 6 1/2 month old BA pullet (was hatched June 10 and turns 7 months on January 10th) - she's been laying for a few weeks now - definitely a female:
I've only owned 1 cochin and that one was obviously a roo by 6 weeks of age (large comb & wattles - started crowing by about 8 weeks of age)- I see rounded hackle feathers on Rabia - if this cochin really is 8 months old, I'd have to guess pullet - if... the OP made a mistake on age and it is a couple months younger, than I'd say roo based on comb size.
1. Blue Cochin, cockerel
2. White Langshan- cockerel
3. Does he have feathers on his legs? From the photo, it appears he does. If so, he is a black Langshan cockerel.
Quote:
Yes! Tony does have feathered legs. I've thought that Fatty and Tony were the same breed but didn't know anything about Langshans. Now that I've read up on them, I think they are both definitely Langshans and both cockerels. We've had a feeling Rabia was a cockerel, too, and seems like the consensus is that he is.