I know everyone wants to be a nice as possible on BYC. I also think that we should see a clearer picture of the breeders/sellers and how they rate. There are alot of complaints about how eggs are packaged, eggs never recieved but paid for,sellers refusing to respond to PM or email, etc. I think it's only fair to see both sides of the picture. I have dealt with someone that did a poor job of packing and only after posting about it did I then recieve 3 PM's from members had the same experience with this same seller. Clearly I would have liked to have been better informed before my purchase. I believe that sellers would strive to do a better job if they knew someone would give negative feedback. I don't mean being rude or mean but being able to state the facts of their experience so other members could make a more informed choice when making a purchase or trade. IM sure the mods will say no as it could start problems but it also creates problems when members are dissappointed by a bad experience.