Broodies don't get outside enough to wear the nails down, great that you got them trimmed!Thankyou so much, just feel totally new to all this, and just want to look after them as best i can, I noticed the broody one seemed to keep tucking one leg up, so i bathed her feet and noticed that some of her nails were really long, so I trimmed them a little, being careful not to go to close to the vein, the other hens feet were fine, think it might be because the other never wants to come out of the coop, therefore not naturally keeping her nails in trim
If these eggs are unfertilized I would definitely take them away. I usually drag broodies out of the box several times a day for sustenance and get them outside too for dust bathing. Some broodies don't take good enough care of themselves, so do it for them. Just watch out for her, give her a bit more attention and she will do fine.