I can only guess it’s the age you are doing it or the way you are doing it. I checked mine EVERY single day until they hit the magic spot and the clarity was there. Their heads MUST be secured. They MUST be fully relaxed. That is not at all what your pics showed. The woman in TS held them each for a total of about 15 seconds. The males had their legs up for a few seconds and then lowered them down as they relaxed. The females relaxed as well, but their legs stayed up. You have to hold them a few seconds past when they are nice and calm and happy looking.
Ah, yeah, they definitely didn't have their heads secured or anything. They're a lot older than I usually have done this with and I needed one hand to take the pictures, so I couldn't support their heads at the same time. But, I can assure you that I did wait until they were fully relaxed before taking those pictures, and it would have taken me at least a little more time on top of that to pull my phone out of my pocket, open the camera, get it to focus on them, and snap the picture, all with one hand. As for the previous tests, I feel like I held them pretty securely, but since I don't remember for sure, I guess I can't really be confident in that.
I have chicks hatching now and some that are about one week old as well, so I'll start testing them this weekend and see what happens! I should be able to secure them better as they're much smaller than the chicks I posted the pictures of before. I'll snap a picture or two when I do so you can tell me if I'm holding them right.
I have had to put mama in a cage so they can see her and have them outside the cage with a heater. I put their food and water next to hers. That way when she tries to cluck them to her for food, they see theirs and eat it without being stressed. She was running them ragged and never stopping to warm them. And then jumping on them! When they try to get under her to get warm, she sends them flying with her insane scratching. She is so over stimulated for some reason that she can’t stop moving and scratching. When she does stop to warm them, which is rare, she only squats down to about 1-2 inches from the ground. It’s bizarre. She is let out of the cage a few times a day and then to put them to bed. She manages to keep them warm at night, plus it’s been very warm. Baby seems good today after being able to rest and stay warm for a couple of days.![]()
Good to hear that the little one has been able to recover! Sounds like the right choice to split them off, mama sounds crazy!! No idea what gets into their heads, but I guess you can only hope she does better or send her packing to broody jail next time and never let her hatch again.
I took them mostly for record keeping, though. If you'd prefer it, I'll just type out the results next time.

