The reason you need to do something fast is because usually by the third day after hatching the momma will take all chicks with her and leave the nest for a new nest area.
Yes, two at a time is fine. I've never waited any length of time between putting eggs or chicks under my broodies. I've put up to eight under one at the same time during broad daylight. Of course she was a silky so that might explain it. The method of slipping eggs or chicks under a broody depends on the broody and her temperament. If she's docile you can cup the baby in your hand and slide it under her without secrecy. If she's not docile, you will want darkened surroundings and make sure she doesn't see what you did or she might think it's a nest invader. Always still cup the baby so that if the broody pecks she gets your hand and not the chicks head.
I wouldn't move the milk crate if she feels comfortable there. If the other chicks are due to hatch within a few days you could try and slip them under her at her new nest location, but if there's a large gap in ages, I would be ready to do something else with the second batch of chicks, like put them under another broody or into a brooder. Again it depends on your broodies temperament and the type of chicks you are putting under her.
I have put 4 under her today, during daylight and all she has done is to look at them and lightly peck at their beaks. She is a Salmon Favorolle, she is supposed to be a good mother by breed, right? Nice temperament? She growls and does a threatening posture toward me but the only time she came close to pecking me was when I discovered the baby that had hatched under her.
Today, I couldn't find the chick that had hatched under her, it had fallen or gotten out of the milk crate. I put it back with no problems.
If the eggs under her don't hatch soon, I will bring them in, candle them and see if there is any life, if so, I will put them in the incubator.
The chicks/eggs are barnyard mixes.
Last edited: