I had to get scientific on this... its my nature. Its so hard to tell who's bigger without weighing them. Lots of them pooped in the holding pen, so I hope they didn't throw off their weight too much.
I am now leaning toward keeping 2...or maybe even 3 of the roos. Plus my BLRW and the lucky speckled sussex who gets chosen. I really shouldn't keep more than that because I have to consider (even if I surpass) my legal limit of fowl. Plus, I only have one breeding pen. And when I say I have it, what I mean is I am currently procrastinating my work on it to make it useable. Right now I have a frame with a chicken wire roof. And a pile of scrap wood and some misc hardware. And a door. I have to go find the rest of the wood I will need. But it's hot and I hate this step of the building process. So here I am!
My plan is to have a rooster pen, my free range flock, and the breeder pen all full of chickens. I will rotate roosters through the free range flock and the breeding pen one at a time. The hens will switch off between free ranging and the breeding pen when I want eggs from them with the rooster of the month. The only other option would be to have only 3 roos TOTAL and use both pens as breeder pens, though the grow out/rooster pen does not have a very nice nest box set-up.
So choices... I really like Easter. He and (sadly) Wings and Condor are the sweetest boys. But of the potential keepers, I like Easter best. I was surprised Fox was so big- I really thought buttercup was bigger. Fox has no mottling that I have noticed, but yes, Big Bluetail is faintly mottled... and has some odd dark lacing on his chest, though it doesn't show up well in pics. The ones I just can't decide between are Nameless, Easter, Big Bluetail, and sometimes Buttercup (though I am not very fond of him- he's a vicious toe-biter!) Most days, I think Easter and Nameless are the two. I could keep them and take Big Bluetail and a few hens to the swap to sell as a set. Or keep Easter and Big Bluetail, and take Nameless to the swap. I really want to keep Easter though. But Nameless is so pretty and Bluetail is so big...This is so hard! I am also worried that Nameless looks like he might have faint barring on his neck, but its so hard to tell.
If this effects the roo choices, the other breeds I have to cross with them are Buff orps, Speckled Sussex, and just as an experiment, some Blue Laced Red Wyandottes. All of these will add some size!
I am completely lost about which hens to keep too. I have been trying to tempt other Oregonians into working on Alohas and I might take sets of the culls to the chicken swap. Obviously Digit and Blackbeak are in- great colors/patterns. Puffy, Snowflake and Sprinkles all have nice bright colors and lots of white spots. Flecks and Goldy are beautiful and on the bigger end. Those are the ones I am thinking I should keep. But Elipses and Calli are kinda big. But there isn't much size difference between most of them. I don't know.
So many pretty boys... it isn't fair!