A for Orpingtons being a "good breed" I think "good" is in the eye of the beholder. Its what you want. I have had Orphingtons for over 20yrs. Started with Buffs and have had the Blues ( blacks and splashes) before they had splash. It used to be whites and blacks, now you don't ever see whites in the blue lines. Just to show my age a bit LOL.
They have survived as a breed on my farm because they are useful. If you see my webpage you can read more about them and why I don't have any other breed.
I can take chicks out of the incubator and hand them directly over to a hen and she will do a bang up job. I had one hen last year that almost gave her life for chicks she didn't even hatch. A coon was dragging her down the hill when I shot him. The hen was ripped open and her gutts hanging out. She had never really been handled but I was able to stitch her up with out help as she stayed quiet so I could help her. In order not to stress her I put her back with her chicks and she not only continued to raise them, even though I know she was in pain, she is alive only due to her mothering ability and will to live for those chicks. She will be a foster again this year. This is the sort of respect these birds demand as mothers.
They lay good sized eggs all winter long. They forage well, they are calm, and easy to handle. I have only had one rooster in all these years that was aggressive. I kept him to help train the guardian dogs. Pups get the picture fast when a rooster puts them in their place. The cockerels can be held longer to see how they mature and extras butchered older and still very good, even for frying when held back. I just don't have a bad thing to say about these birds. I admire them, I respect them, and they have fed my family in a way that few breeds could. Try raising 2 teen boys with a breed that won't produce.
In that time my kids wanted to show at APA shows. They never failed to come home with top honors. I now have the 50/50 UK, US strain and although fertility has dropped since I did that, It is now picking back up as I have made a few tweeks in the breedings. I haven't shown for years, but.. I do plan to show this year, not knowing what the fad is these days.. Im sure that the old tried and true Orph will alwasy hold its own.
Im a bit prejudice, however I do think this breed is worth any investment for your homestead, or your show string. They are wonderful with children, pets and will never let you down. Thats just my opinion, but its an opinion this breed worked hard in my home to create.