As Dave and others have said - only you know your son. With that being said - our 18 y/o daughter decided she no longer wanted to live in our home back in May, the week she graduated high school. She up and left with 3 guys she met online..and is living with them, one being her "boyfriend".
Our daughter was raised better than that, however - our daughter was and is very lazy, which was the constant source of arguements in our home. She did not like being told to do anything - regardless of what it was. She threw away her college - she threw away her health insurance until the age of 24 ....she threw it all away - and why? Because she "knows best". Uh huh... she cant wipe her butt right now because she cant afford toilet paper..but she "knows everything." And as of next week, she and her "Mr. Wonderful" are homeless.... - did I mention she isnt working anywhere nor looking for active employment? Oh. and neither is Mr. Wonderful.... she's been living off of graduation money - that was meant for college - the college that she isnt going to because of "Mr. Wonderful". Dont get me started....
We did the SAME THING you did OP - we didnt make her work to earn her things - even to donate her time at the homeless shelters - food banks - SOMETHING...... we let her have her "social networking" - and.... look what happened. She had one job when she turned 15 (with a permit) for 3 months and our three rules and they were: she had to keep her grades up, no dating anyone at work, and as far as dating went - she was allowed to date 2 years older but they had to be IN high school. She managed to break all 3 rules within 2 months of working and lied the entire time.
Out the door went the job and the guy she was messing with knew she was underaged (he was nearly 20) - so Dad had to have a little "talk" with idiot quite a few times. Dad walked her in there and told the boss she quit right there on the spot - that was her last job..... We are not very strict but we DO have laws and rules that will be abided by, there are chores to get done and school - well that was her "job" - with a 4.0 GPA - she threw it all away for some loser guy. Does she drink? Nope.. drugs? Nope... just hell bent on not doing what anyone tells her to do - and there you go.
MAKE YOUR SON get a job - make him know the value of earning his way, either through paying for his own cell bill, car insurance, car payment, gas money for you driving him..SOMETHING... trust me, you (nor he) will regret it. He may balk about it at first, but he is 17 and needs to know Mom and Dad will not always be there to pay his bills and bail him out. He needs to own up and start being responsible for himself. Too many kids now a days (and even into their 20's) are too dependent on Mom and Dad because Mom and Dad let them be. If I had to do it again... our daughter would have been out there busting tail flipping burgers for all I care (which ...she thinks is "beneath her" - and I about slapped her for saying that, but I didnt... ungrateful brat
). I dont think you're treating your son like a "baby" by asking or telling him to do things or wanting to know his whereabouts - you pay his bills.. YOU and DAD - so you have every right to know where he is, at all times - and he is a minor - so it is your responsibility by law to ensure you know where he is. If he gets in trouble..you are liable, its that simple. Does that mean make it Fort Knox? Noooo.. but.. I think you understand what I'm saying here. You are the parent... he is the child.
As you wrote - no one did it for you... and no one did it for me or my husband either. We worked from the time we were allowed to by law - and before that..we did odd jobs (babysitting, mowing yards, raking leaves, etc) to earn money. We earned our own way in life as did many others on here from our generation I'm sure that are reading this. Does it mean we're "bad parents" for making our kids do the same thing we did? ABSOLUTELY NOT! It means we are teaching them the value of work - that you must earn your own way and not to rely on anyone or "the system" to pay their way
Hugs to you and may it all work out the way you want it.


We did the SAME THING you did OP - we didnt make her work to earn her things - even to donate her time at the homeless shelters - food banks - SOMETHING...... we let her have her "social networking" - and.... look what happened. She had one job when she turned 15 (with a permit) for 3 months and our three rules and they were: she had to keep her grades up, no dating anyone at work, and as far as dating went - she was allowed to date 2 years older but they had to be IN high school. She managed to break all 3 rules within 2 months of working and lied the entire time.

MAKE YOUR SON get a job - make him know the value of earning his way, either through paying for his own cell bill, car insurance, car payment, gas money for you driving him..SOMETHING... trust me, you (nor he) will regret it. He may balk about it at first, but he is 17 and needs to know Mom and Dad will not always be there to pay his bills and bail him out. He needs to own up and start being responsible for himself. Too many kids now a days (and even into their 20's) are too dependent on Mom and Dad because Mom and Dad let them be. If I had to do it again... our daughter would have been out there busting tail flipping burgers for all I care (which ...she thinks is "beneath her" - and I about slapped her for saying that, but I didnt... ungrateful brat


As you wrote - no one did it for you... and no one did it for me or my husband either. We worked from the time we were allowed to by law - and before that..we did odd jobs (babysitting, mowing yards, raking leaves, etc) to earn money. We earned our own way in life as did many others on here from our generation I'm sure that are reading this. Does it mean we're "bad parents" for making our kids do the same thing we did? ABSOLUTELY NOT! It means we are teaching them the value of work - that you must earn your own way and not to rely on anyone or "the system" to pay their way

Hugs to you and may it all work out the way you want it.
Last edited: