Hi Robert. I’m not sure if you were addressing me or not, but I’ll bite because I’m very interested in what you’re saying here. The picture here was a post by Speckledhen and I replied to it. I was throwing some ideas I had out there to get feedback on. I was under the impression that occasional broodiness was something desired in Heritage strains, but I may be completely wrong there. What you’re saying makes perfect sense, egg production and the tendency toward overly broodiness would seem counterproductive.
Could someone tell me what line this Barred Rock Male came from?????????????
Notice his tail. Is it a good one???
I read your post last night about getting Barred Plymouth Rocks and wanting to cross four different strains into a line and then choosing the traits that you want or think you would like in a Plymouth Rock.
I have been fooling with White Rock Large fowl off and on for 24 years. I did not really want them but my childhood friend from the 60s shipped them to me anyway. They where fluffy and they were pretty and they had bunny tails and they had fluff in their rear ends and they would not hatch. So I kept working on feather quality and egg production to breed out the fluffy ness and in five years I had egg laying machines, tight feathered typey Plymouth Rocks and I breed the Cochin genes right out of them. Chicks hatched like pop corn and once and a while I would get a broody hen when the weather go hot down here in April or may. I have studied many years of Rhode Island Red Journals and Plymouth Rock Monthlies from 1912 to 1944 when they stopped printtting them. I have read lots of newsletters and journals for both dual purpose breeds and no one ever has wanted a broody strain of Rocks or Reds.
Why you are going backwards on the real traits of the Rock or a Red. If that's what you want for your goals go for it. But there are other chickens you can have to raise your baby chicks. I have Silkies and Buff Brahma bantams and large fowl Salmon Favolieors would work good to but to make a Rock or Red a Heritage type fowl broodiness will take away the traits you are trying to put breeding pressure on.
Now would I go out and buy four strains of chicks from four different breeders and cross them all up? no
I would go to a guy who all ready did it with three strains in North Carolina and get ten chicks from him.
Then I would raise me two great males three good females from the ten chicks and strain a line breeding program to my fancy or my mind's eye. His name is Jamey Duckworth. How do I know him.??He was the first person or Club Member I helped get going when I became the Secretary of the Plymouth Rock Fanciers Club of America. He uses the old fashion method called the Hogan method of culling.
It works very well for him and he has a fine strain of dual purpose Barred Plymouth Rocks and they will adapt very well to your climate. You don't want to get some from Calif and some from Wisconsin and some from Maine you want birds that have all ready adapted to your region that you live in. His would be perfect. Maybe I can save you five to ten years of work and $10,000 in feed prices on your hunt for a good line. Yes you can eat the culls but you also want to see progress in the goals that you want. If you don't go about it correctly with barred rocks you will be like hundreds who have tried before you. You can count the good breeders on one hand every decade for the past 50 years. Not a easy breed or color pattern to tackle that's why they are hard to locate good ones. I mean good ones. Not the so so 91 to 92 point barred that have black and white feathers. The ones at the feed store that I see are breed for one purpose and that is egg production and that is fine. I bet there are 10,000 of them alive right now in the USA but the old fashion Barred Rocks pictures above maybe 500 to 800 this time of the year. We have been pushing them hard for the past three years and more folks have them than ever.
Hope this helps you. Please get some and try your hand at them and if interested I can locate Jamie for you.
Also I was under the impression that a lot of the Heritage strains were having issues with fertility/hatchability which may not be the case either and that is the only reason I was asking about or wondering if there was a need for a line focusing on utility first. It sounds like I may have jumped to some conclusions there.
At any rate, I may be very appreciative if you could point me toward Mr. Duckworth. A strain from North Carolina already acclimated to my climate/area sounds like a good start.
I have a long way to go; I have to learn about the SOP before I can cull effectively, hehe. I may not be ready to jump into it right away as I’m just getting my feet wet thinking I would like to breed Plymouth Rocks, but I do believe the Barred Rock is the one I will most likely want to breed. I would definitely appreciate the contact information for the future. I learn pretty quickly though and I can get a lil obsessive too, hehe, so the future may be six months.
I’ll be looking into what utility traits as well as type are most desirable in Rocks, but I think you’ve already steered me in some good directions.
Thank you very much for the information!
Last edited: