Quote:
Which is completely natural for the chicken...what is unnatural is the commercial practice of forcing them to lay or grow year round by heating or lighting them, regardless of climatic changes that are normal, forcing a normal laying or growing slow down on the chickens. All of that is for a purpose, so when we heat them or light them artificially, we are going against their natural habitat and environment and forcing them to produce or grow quickly and abnormally~that's not optimal, that's just cruel. And, no, all chickens were not derived in the tropics and therefore must be kept in tropical climes to be be natural....clearly some breeds are more suited to northern climates and some are more suited to tropical climates.
If I were going to copy a practice that was optimal and more safe for the chickens, I'd certainly not model my poultry management off commercial practices....the most cruel and inhumane system on Earth and kills millions of birds a year due to their unnatural habitats. Horrible, cruel deaths.
Quote:
Have you ever tried that? Wore a down suit from your head down to your knees while trying to exist~even for a short time~comfortably in a climate controlled environment? I have.....it's horribly uncomfortable!!!! Hot and humid, nigh enough to smother a person. Unless you were someone that had poor circulation and could not maintain normal body temps, a down suit like a chicken wears while in a climate controlled setting is just miserable.
Comparing chickens~ideally outfitted for life in the outside temps during winter~with people who have no fur, down or feathers to protect them is just ridiculous. Humans are designed to live indoors in cold weather and chickens are designed to live outdoors and have the increased metabolism to do so...there really is no comparison at all.
Quote:
Now, pump up your body heat to 104 or even 113, slip on that down suit again and sit in your climate controlled environment....
Quote:
A chicken that lives in a house full time is drastically different than a chicken that lives outdoors and moves from indoors to outdoors at will during the winter months. One has grown the appropriate feathering to live in a climate controlled~for human living~house and stays in that house at all times during the winter months.... and the other has developed the proper coat for outside living where the temps fluctuate from day to night, from season to season and at any given moment. One can not live comfortably outdoors any longer because some human thought it would be kind to make them live in a human environment and the other is living a more natural life outdoors, in a bird's natural climate.
Creating a "house" like environment for a flock that moves from the house to the outside and back again, while being too hot in the house, getting humid from it all and then moving out into the cold to escape it, then getting chilled due to the humidity in their coat when it is exposed to the outdoor temps...that's putting huge amounts of stress on the bird's body and can compromise their ability to fight off disease/illness. Furthermore, it's just not necessary to do all that when the bird is designed to withstand cold temps just fine.
All these comparisons are not even comparing apples and oranges but more like buses and daylight savings time. One has absolutely nothing to do with the other because you simply cannot, on any level, compare a chicken to a human. Ever. Different creatures with different needs and different designs for those needs.
More about these differences....
Quote:
While the poster giving the advice might have been a little too plain spoken for many, he/she had a point....too much plastic, too much insulation, too much battening down the hatches can create conditions in a coop that lead to more illness and transmission of that illness, particularly in the winter months when many such pathogens thrive well in a warm, humid coop that has very little fresh air flow and chickens living more closely together than they do in the warmer months.
I'm in agreement. There's reasonable and normal precautions one can take to insure chickens are comfortable in colder climates and then there is over doing it and thinking one is doing them a favor. Free advice is, by it's very nature, free for the taking....or the leaving. One can choose without getting all worked up about it.