There is never a silly question, but I'll bet there are a buch of very busy or tired people. Red Stars are awesome egg layers, but their eggs are a light beige where as the RIR are a brown. They both have great qualitities and I have both breeds, but if I had my choice I would take the RIR anytime. In my experience the RIR are much more personable. Although that may be because somone else raised them for the first three and a half months. I do know that the 7 10 week olds are shaping up to be quite the characters. We were sure hoping that ours were RIR, but you get what you get. I think the next time I need some replacements I will order specific breeds.