Yes, I know the breed. Many friends hunt with that breed. Smart and exceptional bird dogs. I have retrievers (golden and a lab). My dogs are trained to hunt mostly upland game and compete, and they really really really love hunting birds. They are beside themselves with these guinea, in particular. They are smart boys, so we will get it worked out because we must, but ...
My question is this: do you or did you hunt your German Shorthair? Did he figure out that birds at home are family and birds in the field are game all by himself? Was it automatic or was there a learning curve?
Not to be a snob or to imply that your dog is otherwise (please forgive if I sound like it), but my dogs are highly bred for retrieving and competing, and the lab, in particular, is obsessive about retrieving and hunting. He is soft mouthed, so he does not kill the birds he retrieves, but the terror, the chaos, the possibility of accidental injury, etc... no can do. The golden has killed raccoons and oppossums here, but he would also like to take apart the two "barn" cats left behind by previous owner, so we have that problem to deal with (making them get along) also.
Other than the e-collar (in formal training), my dogs have never gotten anything other than an open handed swat on the butt except my lab got a burn for running through my garden .. and that was the end of that. They are 9 and 7.
Do you think the e-collar is a bad idea for this task? Any other suggestions?