I don't usually cuddle the roosters here but for your sake I've been sniffing the odd rooster as the opportunities arose.
None of those I've sniffed ( they have not been impressed by the sniffing I might add) smell very strongly but they do smell differently to the hens.
I'll do further investigation when the peck wounds on my nose have healed.
Appearance is very important for the average rooster. I have had one, or two who were a little less diligent about bathing and grooming, but I haven't had a rooster have his tail stripped by domineering hens yet. I would be hard pressed to decide if any change in demeanor was due to the indignity of being bullied by a hen,
or his actual appearance.
However, going by the expression on young Cillins face in the picture below if you asked him if his tail feathers mattered that much I imagine he would respond with something like 'would you be happy looking like this'.
I should point out that no animals were hurt in conducting this investigation and if you want to know what happened, ask the weasel.
View attachment 1944466