These were my thoughts, too. Are you planning on breeding? If so, you don't want your abnormal one breeding your hens anyway. He could pass on both his physical and temperamental traits to his offspring. If you're not planning on breeding, you would be doing your hens a favor by getting rid of him. It's not fair to them to stress them out with his aggressive behavior, plus the two roosters fighting for dominance by gang-breeding them. I would not want to cause that much stress for my hens. I tend to keep or get rid of chickens for the good of the whole flock, not just the needs of one bird. I just made the decision tonight that when butchering day comes, I have a bully hen that I've had for 3 years that will be on that list. I've seen her attack another chicken just out of the blue, more than once. She needs to go to keep peace and harmony in my flock.Um... why are you keeping a roo that you say is dangerous? And, why do you have any roos at all? Your abnormal roo, the one who is "dangerous" should not be allowed to play in the gene pool anyways. I'd get rid of him, and maybe the other one also.