I love this thread! Lots of good info on keeping roosters without being anti-rooster! You've all been very helpful to me and answered all my questions with good advice...thank you!
Now I am looking for a little more:
I am trying to decide about my boys, and how to make life better for my girls...I have 2 young men (supposed to be girls) with my 11 pullets, who are just starting to lay...all 20 weeks old, raised together. The EE is clearly the #1, and a SLW as #2. They are not fighting, but if #2 mounts a girl, #1 runs over and shoves him off, and sometimes jumps right on her. They seem to be working out their aggression with each other ~ on the girls. I almost wish they would fight each other instead of what they put the girls through. I feel like it is too much on the girls; I know 2 with 11 is not a good ratio. So I'm trying to decide the best thing to do. Separate? Cull one?
We were not going to have a rooster, but when I realized we did, I decided to just see how it went. I hadn't planned to hatch eggs, but now that I have the option, I kind of like the idea. We also have lots of predators, including hawks, and we had a raven attack that #1 successfully kept them safe through. So, should I choose one to cull? I don't really know the right way to use a bachelor pad. Can someone talk me through how they work? If they have a bachelor pad, do they get to mix back in with the girls after they've had a break? Or do they kind of live in isolation forever? They don't free range, really, but they do get some "supervised" time out of their run in the morning and evening. Would the boys get to go out with the girls?
Out of the two, #1 is my least favorite, although he does a good job being a rooster, and #2 just sort of exists. I guess that is the way it should be. He isn't there to be my friend, but to do his job. #1 challenges me, a little, but the better I am at ignoring him, the better our relationship. I don't see him as aggressive as much as just protective. He doesn't come after me, but he is always on guard when I am in the run or coop. They both crow, but I hardly ever hear #2. #2 just sort of goes about his day. I assume if I cull #1, #2 will take his place, and likely be the same way?