Rooster poll! Let's tally opinions!

Which role do you think is crucial in producing well behaved roosters?

  • Benevolent provider behavior (food, H2O, distance)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • The snuggly mommy

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • The BIG roo of the world

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Something combining the above

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    0
This is an interesting thread. Roosters. Hmmm. I like roosters, but I have exceedingly high standards for rooster behavior. Which of course means that I don't have a mature rooster on the property. I've had 3 that lived to maturity in the past, and it just didn't work out the way I wanted.

The first one came with my original flock of POL pullets. He was a free range bird who had never been fooled with much. I continued in that tradition, and things went well for a good long time. Then he started getting uppity with me, and the husband put a quick end to that. We used all of his sons for meat birds, because I felt that I didn't need a rooster. Really...

Then I started hatching (shipped) eggs and naturally I got a lot of roosters. I have sold or given away twenty-some odd roosters over the past couple of years. Maybe more. I'm not a huge hatcher, but I have to appease my broody hens from time to time.

I kept two roos last year. Each had his own pen and flock of hens. They were lovely birds, and I enjoyed them for quite a while. They were very different personality-wise. One was quite friendly. So I interacted with him a lot more. I didn't hold or cuddle him, but I sat with him and hand fed him, and just generally worshipped the ground he walked on. He grew into a manfighter. Or womanfighter, as the case may be. Now, I thought that I knew what a manfighter was. I thought my first roo was a manfighter when he occasionally made a running pass at the back of my legs. No, he was actually a great big wuss. This guy would go toe to toe with me. Head on, no backing down, fight to the death. I'm still here, he's dead. Very sad situation. I was in love with him.

The other rooster was very cautious of people. He wouldn't even look you in the face. I liked him, too. He was drop dead gorgeous. But no huggie/smoochie going on. I could live with his behavior toward people. I don't think I would ever have had to deal with him attacking me. I could be wrong about that. But anyway, he didn't make the grade because he was very, very rough with the hens. So he went the way of the rooster, too. (Delicious.)

I have two of his sons now. (I wouldn't have dreamed of keeping any sons of the manfighter.) These two little fellas are about 16 weeks old, and their hormones are raging. I don't handle them. Just enough to do whatever routine maintenance needs to be done, and I take them off the roost for that. They had started to cause a problem at free range time, wanting to molest the hens, which is what teenage roosters do. So my husband started supervising free range, and had knocked them into shape in no time. I say that in a completely nonviolent way. He doesn't actually knock them around. It's an amazement to me what his presence does to their behavior. He is clearly the alpha roo. I'm not sure where I am failing in this department! It's true that he's nearly a foot taller than me and outweighs me by a good 100 pounds, but that's not it at all. It's his attitude. He can and will chop their heads off without batting an eye. He is not emotionally involved with them in any way, and would prefer it if they didn't exist. They exist only because I want to try and find this mythological great roo that I keep hearing about.

I have decided to try something new this year. A bachelor pen. I have two broody pens. They are now bachelor pens. I moved the two little fellas last night. I can't see any reason why they should be allowed to mess up my hens' feathers all winter long. I don't need any hatching eggs. The girls I would want to mate them to aren't even laying yet. So I'm gonna give that a try. It may be a terrible idea, but it's a new one, so we won't know until we try.

I also have two younger roos of a different breed. Adorable! I can't get enough of them before their hormones kick in. When that happens, they can also go to a bachelor pen, if necessary. A separate one, of course.

So, there's my sad story. I've never had an acceptable rooster. It's true that I generally rid myself of their obnoxious presence at or before 4 months of age. So it's possible that I've sent some wonderful roos on to good homes, or to the crockpot. I don't cuddle them, but the one I handled the most frequently turned out to be the worst of the lot. Coincidence? I don't know. None of them have ever dared to try anything untoward on my husband. He wishes they would. But they know better.
wink.png
 
IVe got a barred rock roo,,,,and for the most parts, he's pretty good with me. Every so often he will sort of come at me, but I go right at him, raised voice...'do you need a snuggle?'....Ive had to chase him with the broom once or twice to remind him whos the real boss. And for the most part, these little interactions keep him from getting too aggressive with me. However, if someone else enters the run, or their free range area, he does like to assert himself. So we are still a little up in the air as to what to do with him. If it was me, id stew him, but everyone else likes him,,,he crows very nice...etc etc...So for now he is safe,,,,
 
I love all of these experiences being in one spot.

I am a snuggler. I admit it, and I don't diaper them, but do carry them around nuzzling them and generally acting crazy. I love my boys and my girls...

The boys make little noises at me just like the girls, and for the most part, they act that way with any humans- not just me. I don't know what I can attribute it to or how it translates in chicken psychology, but I like to sit and chill w/my birds on the chicken bench I keep covered (they like it too, so it has to be kept covered) out in the yard.

It seems like, for the most part, the birds tend to grow into the role most people create for them. I find that very interesting and hope not to have my hopes of endless snuggly roosters dashed at some point in the future.
 
I don't feel I can even respond to the poll, since at this point I'm on my first cockerel (who was supposed to be a pullet) who is only somewhere between 18-20 weeks old - and I have absolutely no idea what I'm doing.
idunno.gif
I held him a lot when he was a chick and I thought they were all pullets...as he's gotten older he's made it quite obvious that he does not care for cuddling, so I only pick him up once a week or so to check him over and let my 5 year old pet him. And, yes, kiss him.
smile.png
All I can say is that so far he's been good, even though his hormones have fully kicked in. He's not the cuddly type but he doesn't stand back and give me the stink eye, either - he has a lot to say to me every time I go out there with food and treats, and I'm pretty sure most of it is along the lines of "Hey, lady! Where've you been? A guy could starve around here! Do you know how much work it is keeping these girls in line? Oh, the stories I could tell you..."

He's a Production Red and I keep hearing that he's going to turn into a big meanie...I kind of hope not, because he's beautiful, and so far is good to the girls. He's trying to mate with them at this point but hasn't been overly aggressive about it yet.
 
Nature, but nurture can't hurt. I have an OEGB roo who wasn't very friendly towards me as a chick. He was more scared than anything. He's now grown into a chipper, goofy boy who approaches me without fear (but he's not a lap roo), and can be picked up easily with one hand without the slightest trace of fuss. He'll just calmly sit in my hand until I put him down, then he'll shake his feathers, let out a little chuckle, and go about his business.

My other roo, a Silkie, follows me around like a dog. When he sees me come into the yard, he runs up to me, drops a feather, dances for me, then strolls up to my leg and cuddles up to me so I'll pick him up and hug him. He's so sweet I can put chicks in with him and he'll let them snuggle up to him- he's been "baby sitter" since he was two weeks old. Until he developed streamers, I was so sure he was a pullet because of his disposition.

I had other roosters (some culled, some killed in a mink attack), and gave them as much loving attention as I could. They would either be sweet as can be, friendly but distant, indifferent, or complete A-holes. It seemed to me if they started with a good disposition, they generally kept it - though there were a couple of exceptions. If they started nasty (picked on other chicks, constant stink eye in your general direction, sneaky behaviour, etc.), they stayed that way.

I am a firm believer that you keep and breed the good roos and cull (not give away) the bad ones, so there's greater chance that most of the roos you hatch out will be genetically prone to good behavior. That way you (and the people who get your re-homed birds) will have a less stressful backyard soap opera.
 
Silkie roosters have these single feathers that stick out the back of their crests that are referred to as streamers. My roos' streamers are silver and 3 inches longer than the rest of the crest feathers, which are black. Makes them quite noticeable.
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom