You put the current in place of the original, that's why you got 5.8%, switch them around. But the point is, your bater is dryer than it should be, you want less weight loss. So, bring the humidity up a bit and recheck in 2 days.
Higher humidity, less weight loss, and vice versa.
Ideal weight loss is;
Day 3, 1.9%
Day 5, 3.1%
Day 7, 4.3%
Day 9, 5.6%
Day 11, 6.8%
Day 13, 8%
Day 15, 9.3%
Day 17, 10.5%
Day 18, 11.1%
which hopefully leads to hatch day at 13% weight loss, not that you can or should measure that...;-]