Chick 4 has always been my roo. He has always acted and looked like one. He is very brave and when I bought a 10-month-old rooster he was so sure that he would win the stare-off. I will post later.
Update: Looks like there are two roosters. Number 1 and 4. Any other opinions are more than welcome. Also, I have to chose which rooster I will keep. Number 1 has a really great temperament, but he looks a bit dark for the breed. Any thoughts are welcome. I have also thrown in the mix a Silkie that hatched a week after the others. It is 25% leghorn. Can anyone have a guess at gender for that one too. I posted photos.