I am really wondering about this (in the context of thinking about building another coop). Last year I would have said as you do, Shadrach, but now I notice my birds are often in their coop.
@Solanacae I've noticed on the other threads I follow that people who live in the colder US states and in Canada say their birds don't come out at all some of the days ! So of course it would have to do with climate when temperatures are in the teen f or minus 10c.
But it's not cold where I am, just that the chickens are stressed by the raptors. If we had a small coop type, they would probably be under it or under the trees, but the fact is that they are spending a lot of time (maybe three hours out of the eight of daylight we have) inside the coop. I wonder if age has triggered their change in behaviour, or just stress, but I 'm beginning to think it's nice that they have the choice to be inside if they chose.
Also, I think we made a mistake to cover the run with clear polycarbonate. We thought it would be nice to have more light in there as it's a shady zone, but I believe the chickens don't feel as safe- they can't understand that it's clear only for them and that they are no seen from above.
I completely agree with
@Solanacae. I'm very pessimistic usually about human nature, but I have been quite a few times in my professional life amazed to see that colleagues volunteered to help me on projects when I asked, just because they saw I was really implicated and because they truly had the choice to or not. Also, it always surprised me that some changed their mind- sometimes they decided to help months, or a year after saying no. This made me think that when you give people a choice, try to set an example and show that you will be there whatever happens in the long term, you can be surprised very positively.
I'm very glad it's working out for you and the chickens because you have been really showing dedication and getting results.
What I would be careful about, is that C. doesn't see this as a breach of power and start to work against you.