- Thread starter
- #34,161
No, I don't think Mauss got it wrong; a trifle simplistic perhaps.So, do we think Mauss got it wrong? Or that the shiny hand of commercialism has killed the true idea of the gift? Or is something else at work with all of us saying thanks but no thanks to presents from nearest and dearest?
There is a difference between a thoughtful gift and the almost hysterical purchasing of the products commerce shoves down our throats, bought for the sake of buying something at a particular time of year. From my rather jaundiced view having watched and listened to the Bristol Christmas shopper over the past few weeks, not much thought regarding gift quality and suitability has gone on.
We have had a gift type and cost limit for quite a few Christmases, it just went wrong this year.
I think I've got to the point where I would rather avoid Christmas altogether.
So, for future reference, would the idea of each person bringing something to the feast work better? Their present to all being whatever
We, or some of us do. this every year. Last year I did the cauliflower cheese, Christmas cake and tapas type stuff. This year I did cake and pudding a special pesto and a bottle of port.meal component they provided? A trad Christmas dinner is astonishingly expensive to put on, especially given the number of diners is usually significantly larger than the host typically plans, buys and cooks for. So each person shares the workload and the provisions budget with the others round the table, instead of spending time and money on finding, wrapping and giving additional and unwanted stuff before or after? And then the host just has to co-ordinate, instead of provide everything, while all the social bonds or whatever else it is that traditional gift-giving is supposed to affirm (and which explains how upset some people get when you don't want anything) get affirmed. (Might not work with picky eaters.)
The eldest works out the cost and we split it between us. Three of us helped with bringing food this year and would help with the cooking on the day if the eldest would let us near the stove.

All the above.Have they not been along for a while? Or is it ongoing? Has nothing worked to stop that rat?


