She said/He said Who's right? Who's wrong? No one!

[scflock]

Wow! Thats quite a comb

beautiful!! BCM??

Thanks guys, but his comb is a DQ. It's too big, too meaty, and has too many points. He also has a halo, though not as bad as the others that came with him. Anyone that knows how to critique the faults, feel free, you won't hurt my feelings. Snowbird, if you happen to see this, I would love to hear you note every fault. I need to know what to breed out

 

[Ravynscroft]

Very nice chest... looks good really... you made him sound like Quasi...

 

[scflock]

The 'Red Wheaten' gold in his hackles the halo you were talking about?

Yes. I had 4 in my straight run batch, but the others were much worse. I have a few very dark hens that I can breed him to, but the comb is severe

 

[scflock]

Very nice chest... looks good really... you made him sound like Quasi...

Don has me gun shy...
He's a beautiful bird, and I love him, but I have some things to work on

 

[silkiecuddles]

What else would he be?

SC, is his comb tipped purple?

 

[scflock]

Very nice chest... looks good really... you made him sound like Quasi...

He was smallish for a while, but has really beefed up in the last few months

 

[scflock]

SC, is his comb tipped purple?

Yes, and that's probably not good, either...
He has a carnation comb. If I took a pic from the rear, you could really see the extra points, and would be an automatic DQ for showing

 

[WVduckchick]

Yes, and that's probably not good, either...
He has a carnation comb. If I took a pic from the rear, you could really see the extra points, and would be an automatic DQ for showing

I still think he is gorgeous!!

 

[Schaafty]

Good for the table but get the cross comb out of your breeding pens.

 

[scflock]

I still think he is gorgeous!!

If I had never asked on the eatemup thread I wouldn't know any better. He is a quite beautiful bird, but has faults. Great personality, too, but not much of a gentleman. Gets that from his daddy...