If your chickens free range, keep the first one, since he takes such good care of the girls. His attacking you was his way of protecting his ladies. When you go near the chickens, always carry at least a handful of feed and toss it to him. He will learn that you are not a threat. Also if your chickens free range, keep rooster number two, as a back up rooster,because no matter how careful you are, it is possible to lose a chickens to predators.
Come to think of it, even if you don't free range, keep roosters one and two. You can still tame rooster one down with food.
As for number three, if he was mine, I would have him for supper.
Come to think of it, even if you don't free range, keep roosters one and two. You can still tame rooster one down with food.
As for number three, if he was mine, I would have him for supper.