Should I use an auto egg turner or no turner???

Smokin Silkies

formerly browneyebuttafly
11 Years
Joined
Mar 27, 2009
Messages
1,235
Reaction score
11
Points
194
Location
Western, PA
I tried to hatch chicken eggs a few months ago and failed miserably. Not sure if it was me or just cause they were shipped? Anyways, my daughter wants to try and hatch her own so I told her ok...but I'm not allowed to help. I have an LG still air with auto turner. Has anybody had better experience withOUT the turner vs w/ turner? I'd like to hear some opinions of those of you who have done both...personal experience. I know w/out you'd have to open the bator more but? I think my turner quit turning for a few days, but not sure? Any info would be appreciated. Thanks!!!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
People have a lot of trouble with shipped eggs. To postal service is not the most gentle and if something is marked fragile, it seems the more they see if they can destroy it. So I would say that it was probably more the way the eggs were handled in shipping than during incubating.
If you are using an LG you would be much better off using a turner. The temp in an LG does not hold right to begin with and so if you had to keep opening it to turn eggs then the temp would really be unstable.
We have an LG with turner and have very good luck with it. Here in Florida it is humid enough that we can do dry incubation, which a lot of people frown upon, but it works very well for us. Our hatches are in the 90% to 95% range every time. We have a hatcher that I built that the eggs go into on the 19th day. Yes, I know that eggs are supposed to quit turning on the 18th day. But we let ours go to the 19th day and then to the hatcher where the are still until hatch. We also run our bator at 100 degrees which is lower than should be but this is just what we have found works the best for us. We have hatched over 600 chicks in the last year this way and have very few problems. Out of all those chicks we might have had a total of a dozen that had problems but nothing that wasn't fixable.
You just want to make sure that the temp does not go too high. It is better to let it go cooler than hotter. Hotter will kill a chick, cooler will slow it's growth rate in the egg.
I would suggest getting a good quality thermometer/hygrometer to use. We use a digital weather station for ours. It comes with a remote wireless outdoor ther/hygro pickup that we place in the incubator. The digital readout is in our livingroom so we can see what the temp is at any time. Just really handy as our incubator is in a spare bedroom. Keeps us from having to go check all the time. Plus it is acurate to +/- 1 degree.
Just a few suggestions for you.
Good luck with the hatch.
 
I used an LG, with the turner AND a computer fan to create air movement and keep the temp/humidity steady all around the eggs.

Seemed to work pretty well since of the 36 fertile eggs I had 30 hatch.

I would definately suggest the turner AND a fan (they have instructions on how to rig up a computer fan on this site). Using the turner eliminates the hassle of remembering to turn the eggs manually. All you need to do is take it out after so many days!

Good luck!
 
I used an LG Still air with a turner for 4 hatches, had success with all of them, better with the local eggs though than the shipped. I would definitely use a turner, then you dont have to open the bator so much and the temp stays more stable.


Nancy
 
I agree--have a Hovabator 1602 & never had much luck with it until we added a computer fan & auto-turner--that made a world of difference.
Hatched eggs are always a gamble--I've had some that every one of them were scrambled & did not hatch, & then in my last hatch just this past week I had 100% on one batch & 99% & 95% on the other 2 batches in that incubator--so, you never know, w/hatched eggs. I've never hatched any of my own - that's my goal next year.
 
when i hatched my my chicks in my incubator i used a turner and all of them were born healthy
 
I also have an LG with turner, and failed miserably myself with my last batch of eggs. This time I decided to turn them by hand, and so far out of 15 BBS shipped eggs, it seems as though 10 of them are growing. I will lock down the bator on Monday, which is something I did not do on the 18th day of my last batch. I did not know that I wasn't supposed to open the bator at all after day 18. But anyways...I think a lot of people have good luck when they turn them manually. I do not have a forced air bator. Mine is the still air type. I have been able to stablize my temp when I keep both of the red plugs open, and fill the sections with water. My humidity has been pretty stable between 46 - 53. I am trying to keep the temp at 100 - 101.5. So far so good. Its a trial and error thing...you have to keep trying even if you get discouraged. Good Luck!!
thumbsup.gif
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom