Egg eater or productive flock member, we took her in. She’s here to stay, now, so I suppose it doesn’t really matter much at this point, we’ll do everything we can to give her a good life.
We’ve gone two days and she hasn’t eaten any yet. She laid one both days and left it there in the nest. I’m probably speaking wayyy too soon, though. Ive seen her nose around the eggs a bit and maybe she was thinking of cracking them open, but idk, I didn’t let it go on for too long before I collected them. I’m fortunate in that I am able to work from home, so I can frequently collect their eggs. We also have a camera to watch them, so that helps me be able to go out there right away when a hen gets off the nest. Hoping if i collect them quick enough and leave only the fake ones in there to be pecked at, she’ll learn and we’ll be okay.
Either way she’s welcome to stay. As you said, separating her in her own little coop is an option if she can’t break the habit.