Even poor quality breeder birds are MUCH MUCH better than hatchery. I really don't like hatchery silkies. In my opinion, the silkies from a hatchery are the worst quality of any breed they sell. The crests are just so tiny and they aren't fluffy at all. Lots have problems with silkie chicks from a hatchery missing their extra toe, and cross beak, etc.
Now that I've mentioned that, has anyone ever got a hatchery silkie that was decent quality? If so, which hatchery?
Before I read more, I got some silkie chicks from a feed store. They were from Ideal. In a nut shell, the buff and blue were not good with regard to crests and beards. The blue was the worst in that department but the buff had poor foot feathering. The black has a respectable beard, very nice foot feathering, but a small crest. [However she is the nicest most lovey dearie and I kept her because of that. Just loves to be held and runs up to me. Falls asleep in my arms. She is precious, and very black with a little beetle-sheen in the sun.]
The whites however, and I got two of them two weeks apart so not the same hatch, were really quite nice, oddly enough. The female looked "rattier" as a youngster than the babies I hatched from a breeder, but once she was about 4 months, she was pretty nice.
Here's a few pictures of the white pullet:
I agree with Basel. I too got some feed store chicks that came from Ideal, two white pullets and a black cockerel. I also think the whites are better than the other colors, though the black boy wasn't too bad. They actually turned out better than chicks I bought from an active shower and breeder. I'm sure this is the exception rather than the rule, but it is possible.
I agree with Basel. I too got some feed store chicks that came from Ideal, two white pullets and a black cockerel. I also think the whites are better than the other colors, though the black boy wasn't too bad. They actually turned out better than chicks I bought from an active shower and breeder. I'm sure this is the exception rather than the rule, but it is possible.
Whites generally have bigger crests than other colours anyway, so that is probably why they were okay. Type isn't great on them, but they are a great deal better than some hatchery silkies I've seen!
So if recommending a hatchery if you HAVE to get a hatchery chick, Ideal is better than McMurray?
I agree with Basel. I too got some feed store chicks that came from Ideal, two white pullets and a black cockerel. I also think the whites are better than the other colors, though the black boy wasn't too bad. They actually turned out better than chicks I bought from an active shower and breeder. I'm sure this is the exception rather than the rule, but it is possible.