• giveaway ENDS SOON! Cutest Baby Fowl Photo Contest: Win a Brinsea Maxi 24 EX Connect CLICK HERE!

Song of the Wind ~~Open Warrior Cats RP~~ (Please join!)

Pics
Date sort Score sort
black_cat said:
Tallstar's Revenge is a super edition, not part of the main series. I've read all of them aside from the few books that have come out most recently, and I forgot that not everyone reads obsessively like I do! (Seriously-if I get into a series I will hunt all of the books down until I've read them all.
Click to expand...
Trust me, you're not the only one who reads Warriors obsessively!
 
LittleRaptorLadies said:
What's everybody's favorite Warrior Cat? My absolute favorite is Sorreltail, but I also like Leafpool, Purdy and Jayfeather.
Click to expand...
My favorite is definitely Ivypool. Sorreltail is one of my favorite background characters, too! I like Leafpool as a flat character, but the Erins wrote her so...badly....that it kinda ruins her for me, and her chapters are just so.....boring.....to get through, at least in my opinion.
 
Alyssa-Bee said:
Hmmmm... I have no idea! Maybe Bramblestar... or Jayfeather or Hollyleaf... Ravenpaw... you know what?... I can't pick favorites, It's impossible! :D
Click to expand...
I really like all the cats you listed there aside from Bramblestar...in my opinion, Bramblestar is kinda a jerk, and he's also kinda badly written. To each his own, though!
 
black_cat said:
I really like all the cats you listed there aside from Bramblestar...in my opinion, Bramblestar is kinda a jerk, and he's also kinda badly written. To each his own, though!
Click to expand...
ME TOO. I feel that he was just a bland copy of Firestar. Misunderstood, (Firestar, kittypet; Bramblestar, his father), got into trouble and was overall just BORING. He was also very mean to Squirrelflight, I felt, in her super edition, and he never chose the right thing. The part that REALLY tipped me over the edge was, in A Vision of Shadows (SPOILER ALERT), he separated Violetkit and Twigkit. It broke my heart.
 
black_cat said:
My favorite is definitely Ivypool. Sorreltail is one of my favorite background characters, too! I like Leafpool as a flat character, but the Erins wrote her so...badly....that it kinda ruins her for me, and her chapters are just so.....boring.....to get through, at least in my opinion.
Click to expand...
I really enjoyed her bond with Squirrelflight. I feel that it's as close to a non-mate relationship that we'll ever get in Warriors. And I also like Crowfeather. I've honestly liked him since Midnight.
 
LittleRaptorLadies said:
ME TOO. I feel that he was just a bland copy of Firestar. Misunderstood, (Firestar, kittypet; Bramblestar, his father), got into trouble and was overall just BORING. He was also very mean to Squirrelflight, I felt, in her super edition, and he never chose the right thing. The part that REALLY tipped me over the edge was, in A Vision of Shadows (SPOILER ALERT), he separated Violetkit and Twigkit. It broke my heart.
Click to expand...
Firestar was interesting, because when he was the main character he has more than one side to his personality. Bramblestar is just...so...frustrating. He totally mistreats Squirrelflight, who is a GREAT character.
Now that he's possessed, he acts pretty much the same, and he's clearly supposed to seem evil. I want him to kick the bucket already so that we can have Squirrelstar! Hopefully she'll make Ivypool or Rosepetal deputy.
 
Last edited:
LittleRaptorLadies said:
What's everybody's favorite Warrior Cat? My absolute favorite is Sorreltail, but I also like Leafpool, Purdy and Jayfeather.
Click to expand...
My favorite is definitely GrayWing, from Dawn Of The Clans! Squirrelflight is cool too.

I liked Firestar at first, but in the Power Of Three series he changed. I'll try not to spoil anything, but the Firestar I knew and loved would not have kept such big secrets from his own kin. He would have been honest and not tried to hide their destiny. He was not the same.
 
SoftSilkie said:
My favorite is definitely GrayWing, from Dawn Of The Clans! Squirrelflight is cool too.

I liked Firestar at first, but in the Power Of Three series he changed. I'll try not to spoil anything, but the Firestar I knew and loved would not have kept such big secrets from his own kin. He would have been honest and not tried to hide their destiny. He was not the same.
Click to expand...
Graywing is pretty good! Power of Three is where the writing started to go downhill.......Firestar getting messed up is definitely the Erins' fault.
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom