Still not sure about the one standing in front. The back is definitely a rooster since it has been crowing everyday for the past week! It is also trying to get at the hens. This other (in front) supposedly the same age still has us puzzled. Its tail and saddle feathers point towards cockerel but compared to the other as far as comp and waddle it says pullet to me. Any guesses out there. We showed pics to the man we bought them from and he said pullet, but I don't think he looked very closely. They are supposedly about 5-6 months old.