I probably will keep Magnus, but it would be wrong to breed him, no matter how handsome he is. DD is not going to let me send him to freezer camp even if I had the heart to do it. One of my goals in hatching eggs (all breeds) is to obtain enough birds that I can let them truly free-range and I can afford to lose a few. Magnus will now be one of my free-range, mixed flock birds as he is now one that I can afford to lose.
(though hopefully not)
I believe all of us who have adopted this breed have a responsibility to work to improve, not just breed indiscriminately. It may be a long time before the SFH is accepted into the APA, but if we are not consciencious to breed for the betterment of the breed, it may not be accepted at all. I know most people who are going to own this breed will never show them, but we are the pioneers in this country and all future birds will come from the stock we have right now. If I knew I would NEVER sell a hatching egg, or a chick, or a grown bird to anyone, but ALWAYS keep them to myself, then perhaps I could justify using him to breed. But not only is that not going to be the case, and as I said, I have six other roos to use that at this point appear to be better candidates to breed. I am a novice at this, too, but from what I have read, side sprigs are difficult and time consuming to eliminate without a LOT of culling. I'd rather not do that if I don't have to.
OK, I'll get down off my soapbox now.

I believe all of us who have adopted this breed have a responsibility to work to improve, not just breed indiscriminately. It may be a long time before the SFH is accepted into the APA, but if we are not consciencious to breed for the betterment of the breed, it may not be accepted at all. I know most people who are going to own this breed will never show them, but we are the pioneers in this country and all future birds will come from the stock we have right now. If I knew I would NEVER sell a hatching egg, or a chick, or a grown bird to anyone, but ALWAYS keep them to myself, then perhaps I could justify using him to breed. But not only is that not going to be the case, and as I said, I have six other roos to use that at this point appear to be better candidates to breed. I am a novice at this, too, but from what I have read, side sprigs are difficult and time consuming to eliminate without a LOT of culling. I'd rather not do that if I don't have to.
OK, I'll get down off my soapbox now.