I was thinking about ordering this when I get my incometax. Anyone have any reviews for the either of these Hova Bators?
LINK1,
LINK2,
I really like the digital settings for this one,
another set. Thanks much! IF you know of any better incubators, please do tell!
I was also looking at this incubator.
Any reviews?
I have the small 7 egg capacity
Brinsea and the Genesis Hovabator 1588. The
Brinsea has been my favorite by far except that it doesn't have enough egg capacity in it. I would like to have the larger models but cost is a factor and I'm making do with what I have. My biggest complaint with the
Brinsea is price, but you do get what you pay for in most things and the
Brinsea is pricey but I like it much better.
My complaint with the Genesis is that is has too many temp/humidity fluctuations compared to my
Brinsea. We don't have central heat/air so our house is prone to temp swings and hot/cold areas and this affects the Gensis. It has not affected the
Brinsea at all. But then the plastic of the
Brinsea is a little more of a secure environment compared to essentially a Styrofoam ice chest outfitted with a heating element and a computer fan.
I am having a little bit better time this year because I have turned a "greenhouse shelf", the kind that is a set of shelves that has greenhouse material covering it that you zip open/shut, into a nursery ($20 at
TSC). I put cardboard on the shelves and the incubators are on the shelves inside and so are not getting the brunt of drafts and hot/cold temps in the house. So I'm not seeing quite as big of temp/humidity fluctuations in the Genesis this year with this new setup.
The temp/humidity controller in my Genesis is also questionable as far as accuracy of readings. I've had to "get used" to how it heats and adjust things differently whereas with the
Brinsea, I set that humidity and temp on the normally suggested numbers and have excellent results with it - without a lot of work and messing with the controls. I have put multiple thermom/hygrometers in the Genesis and none had the same results as what the incubator unit itself was reading. And you can't calibrate the Genesis controls.
My other complaint with the Genesis is having to pour water into a tray for humidity - this is messy, and time consuming and not very scientific. I did find an after market humidity pump controller for $80 and now use it. It has decreased the amount of time I deal with humidity issues although I do find it a pain in the butt that I haven't found a way to really affix the tubing so that it doesn't accidently slide out of the incubator or out of the moisture sponge when I move the incubator to check on things. But it beats having a tray of water in the bottom of the incubator.
I have heard recently that someone doesn't like the larger Brinseas for hatching because there isn't a lot of head room in there and they use their
Brinsea 20/40 for incubating but then go to a different incubator like the Genesis to have room for actual hatching. The Genesis does have decent room for hatching, although sometimes it does get a little tight in there when the chicks are running around in there and interfering with unhatched eggs. So I do usually have to remove chicks to give more room to hatch the rest.
If I were limited on funds, I'd get the Genesis before I'd get any of the other similarly built/priced ones. Once you figure out the quirks of your individual machine and environment, it does work. And it was nice that I could go to
TSC and buy one of their cheaper egg turners and it fit inside the Genesis, rather than buying the more expensive egg turner from GQF that they recommend for use in the Genesis.
But if money were not a factor and ease of use was a concern - I prefer the
Brinsea.
I also have one of their EcoGlow warmers and love it to death. I know someone on here had some bad problems with
Brinsea products and electrical issues - cords being unsafe or something - but I"ve had nothing but good luck with my
Brinsea products.