Announcement The Coop Page / Article Rating & Review Project!

Pics
Owners come back.
:old:old:old
You must admit that you notice 80% of the coop pages were created or last edited in 2012 :lau
I’ve been trying to write at least two sentences. Something I like, and something that could be improved.
I write about two to three sentences. The first is a comment on the coop, the second is about the coop page, and the third is things that could be added to both
 
You must admit that you notice 80% of the coop pages were created or last edited in 2012 :lau

I write about two to three sentences. The first is a comment on the coop, the second is about the coop page, and the third is things that could be added to both

There were changes in 2012. One of those changes was a push for coop pages.
If I remember right......

Yup I was a long time lurker. :oops:
 
Haha I had to go back and re-rate some of mine. I started out giving 4 stars to a terrible article because I felt bad, I’m trying to be stricter for the cause!
Yeah, I totally get that, but it's good practice to be as objective as possible. I've definitely seen some ratings (from before this project) that gave pages that should have been a 1 or 2 a 4-star review.

I'm rating all of mine anonymously so I don't have to worry about that. But getting a 1 or a 5 from me is really hard.
Yup, that's definitely a good idea / option. I've done the same before.

What do I do for the coops I have absolutely nothing to say about but have a rating for. Is it okay if I just give stars for those?
YES! please feel comfortable only doing the rating. To be honest, I'd probably just default to having peeps give quick (accurate) ratings on these older coop pages vs. writing reviews... unless there's blatant "WOW, THIS IS AMAZING" or "Ugh, here's a blatant thing that needs fixing" comments that would be helpful.

There were changes in 2012.
Yup! In 2012 we converted from a very clunky articles system (it was pretty bad) to a new system... but in the process all the old articles were imported with the "creation date" of the day they were created.

The pre-2012 system also didn't have any ratings / reviews.
 
My big thing is if they were to comment back on it and be like "why 1 star?" I would be more than happy to go over why and also re-rate once fixed. But I got like 8 with just one picture and no words yesterday that I only gave one star to.. also if its anonymous im sure they can't do that. Not knocking anyone, just trying to give them a fighting chance if they care. But not trying to waste my breath if they dont.
-sav
 
My big thing is if they were to comment back on it and be like "why 1 star?" I would be more than happy to go over why and also re-rate once fixed. But I got like 8 with just one picture and no words yesterday that I only gave one star to.. also if its anonymous im sure they can't do that. Not knocking anyone, just trying to give them a fighting chance if they care. But not trying to waste my breath if they dont.
-sav
Good point. I also struggled with separating my opinion of a good looking coop with an informative and detailed article. After rereading this thread I have a better grasp lol.
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom